Twelve years past the last bell of work, I scour rust from the hidden rooms of the mind. Each poem is a dawn walk, lamp in hand, through the soul’s dim hallways, keeping the joints of the spirit from turning to stone.
A dear friend has crossed the river this week. All night, sleep circled my bed like a bird that would not land.
Then Sunday opened another door of sorrow: our choir director’s father moving from the house of healing to the threshold of hospice, one foot already in the farther light.
His chair stood empty, a small hollow where silence pooled. The organist and her husband stepped into that hollow, and from the pipes and voices a ladder rose. For a moment heaven bent low to listen, though my mind kept drifting like smoke loosed from a censer.
My wife gave away copies of my book, seeds dropped into unknown soil. Someone spoke of an aunt, eighty-six, whose poems had also found their way into the light.
Why do we write as the evening comes? To sweep the dust from memory’s altar? To leave some embers of the heart in our children’s hands? To breathe our names into the wind of what is coming? Or only to carve on the wall of time: I was here. I saw. I loved. I wondered.
For years I have tried to give my children three lanterns: imagining, exploring, loving. Maybe those lanterns have been carrying me all along, writing me into a deeper page.
A poem is not born on paper. It wells up from beneath thought, an underground spring where memory and feeling meet. The moment ripens into feeling, feeling into word, word into song, and the veil of now parts just a little onto eternity.
Then home. Boots, gloves, earmuffs, WQXR humming its quiet psalm. Back to the earth, the oldest sanctuary.
I lifted eight banana trees from their beds and laid them in new ground, eight small Easters hidden in the yard. I filled the graves that were cradles, pushed the cart, carried the dark soil, until my left knee rang its own bell: Enough.
So I slowed down. I slow down more these days, and the slowing is not only loss. Slowness is a kind of lens. Through it I see a bell trembling in the sanctuary, an empty chair holding its absence, my wife walking beside me, a stranger receiving a book, an old poet still bending over the page, a banana root feeling for new earth, the small sermon of a knee, breath going in and out like the tide of God.
Strange Sunday. A friend gone over. A father at the threshold. Music climbing. Poems traveling between strangers. Roots going down in the dark.
And here I stand, between grief and gratitude, between heaven and soil, asking on the Lord’s day: am I only surviving, or am I praising?
Maybe, in the slowing, survival bends its knee and becomes praise, and I am still being shaped in the potter’s patient hands.
Myrrh and linen, forty days of spices, and the son bending low over his father’s face, his tears falling like dew on a fallen cedar.
Egypt mourns seventy days. Then chariots climb toward Canaan, a long sigh of dust going back to the promise.
Beyond the Jordan the grief runs so deep the ground takes a new name: Abel-mizraim. Even a stranger’s land learns how to weep.
In the cave of Machpelah the old pilgrim is laid down among his fathers, a seed tucked into the dark of the promise.
But when the grave closes, the brothers’ old guilt stirs like a buried coal. “What if he remembers?”
They fall at his feet. “We are your servants.” And Joseph weeps. Even now they can’t believe in love.
“Don’t be afraid. Am I in the place of God?” He sets down the scales he was never meant to hold.
“You meant evil against me. God meant it for good, to keep many alive.” The pit was the root, the famine bread was the fruit, and a hidden Gardener tended both.
And I ask myself: whose debts am I still counting? Which old wound have I made into a throne? Where have I sat in the seat that belongs only to You?
He speaks kindly to them. His mercy falls softly over hearts frozen hard, the way snow falls.
Years pass. His great-grandchildren climb onto his knees.
“God will surely visit you. Carry my bones.” He has lived his whole life in Egypt, but his heart has faced east.
They lay him in a coffin. Genesis closes, not with an arrival, but with a door left open.
Keeper of the promise, take the scales out of my hands. Turn my wounds into bread for others, and keep my bones, and my hope, facing Your morning.
[Sad news reached me from Korea. My dear friend, Dr. Sang-Whan Suh, a gifted painter whom I deeply respected and admired, passed away a few days ago. In gratitude for his friendship and the beauty he brought into this world, I offer this poem, “Let It Be,” as my tribute to his passing.]
Only last summer I sat with him in his room, while time, unnoticed, waited at the door.
This fall his daughter sent word that he had crossed the gracious ocean.
Not hurried. Not taken.
He simply entered another work of art and became part of the picture.
Behind thick glasses, beneath those familiar eyebrows, his eyes had always searched for the Master’s hidden intention.
And his weathered hands, touching wood, earth, and paint, seemed to know that nothing is truly unfinished in the Creator’s world.
So come now, my friend. Cross the Pacific without passport or ticket. Come into this room where my heart sometimes loses its way.
Bring your brushes. Paint our songs again upon the waiting canvas of Spring.
And when I travel to Korea, thinking I have left something behind, let me discover that you have gone before me.
Perhaps there is no leaving. Only another road, another color, another canvas.
An old man’s breath, thin as lamp smoke, and twelve sons kneel where the bed meets the dark. “Gather,” he whispers, “and hear Israel, your father.”
Reuben, my first strength, spilled water that wouldn’t stay in the jar. What you defiled will not rise to lead.
Simeon, Levi, your swords rang in the night. Your anger scattered you. Now be scattered seed.
Then the voice warms like coals stirred: Judah, lion’s cub, the scepter rests in your hand until the One arrives whom all the nations will obey. He ties his donkey to the vine, washes his robes in the red blood of grapes.
Zebulun, the sea’s edge. Issachar, the shoulder bent. Dan, a serpent in the dust of the road.
Then, in the middle of the naming, the old man looks up: “I wait for Your salvation, O Lord.”
Gad, raided, strikes back. Asher, bread rich enough for kings. Naphtali, a doe set free.
Joseph, a vine beside a hidden spring, your branches climb the wall. The arrows came, but your bow held, steadied by the hands of the Mighty One of Jacob, the Shepherd, the Stone of Israel. Blessing from the heavens, blessing from the deep.
Benjamin, a wolf at dawn, sharing the spoil by evening.
He doesn’t flatter them. Truth cuts, and it heals. Under every word, one promise holds the twelve.
“Lay me in Machpelah, with my fathers, beside Leah.” He draws his feet into the bed, and the river of breath returns to its Source.
Shepherd of my last hour, when every blessing is spoken, find me with open hands, still waiting for Your salvation.
(I could not find a single criticism to make of the following well-written piece.):
When discussing the causes of the Church’s decline, conservative evangelicals have consistently identified one chief culprit: “Liberal Theology,” which removed the miraculous from Scripture and reduced the Gospel to a lecture on morality.
Historians who take a sober view of the whole sweep of Church history, however, often arrive at a very different diagnosis:
“What corrupted the Church from within was not obscure liberal thought, but the corruption and greed of those who claimed to be the most orthodox.”
If we roll the great screen of history from the Early Church all the way to twenty-first-century South Korea, we begin to see with uncomfortable clarity when the Church lost its vitality and what caused it to collapse.
1. From the Early Church to the Middle Ages: A Temple Brought Down Not by “Heresy,” but by Power and Gold
For the first three hundred years of Christianity, the Church was surrounded on every side by heresies and competing religious philosophies. Gnosticism, Arianism, Marcionism, and other teachings, in many respects far more destructive than modern liberal theology, threatened the Gospel from all directions.
Yet the Early Church did not collapse under these intellectual challenges. On the contrary, shedding its blood in the underground catacombs, it grew stronger and eventually spread throughout the Roman Empire.
The tragedy of the Church began not with an intellectual attack, but with the political triumph of orthodoxy.
Constantine: Blessing or Curse? The Fourth Century
When Christianity became the favored religion of the Roman Empire, yesterday’s martyrs became today’s privileged class. Bishops moved through imperial courts dressed in splendor, and confessions of faith could become political weapons in struggles for power.
Doctrine might have remained thoroughly orthodox, yet the Gospel’s radical spirit and sacrificial character began to disappear.
The Borgia Popes and the Tragedy of Indulgences
The theology that dominated Roman Catholicism immediately before the sixteenth-century Reformation was certainly not liberal theology. It was thoroughly orthodox by the standards of the age, grounded in the scholastic theology of Thomas Aquinas and firmly confessing the Trinity and the divine inspiration of Scripture.
Yet the Roman Church sold indulgences to finance its extravagance and the construction of St. Peter’s Basilica, proclaiming that when a coin rang in the chest, a soul sprang from purgatory toward heaven.
Popes such as Alexander VI, father of Cesare Borgia, became notorious for scandal, intrigue, and political violence.
What brought the medieval Church into disgrace was not biblical higher criticism. It was greed, simony, and corruption multiplying behind the mask of impeccable orthodoxy.
2. The Great Experiment of Modern Western Christianity: Liberalism’s “Euthanasia” versus Conservatism’s “Moral Suicide”
As Christianity entered the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, the Western Church became a vast testing ground for two opposite tendencies, intellectual and ethical.
This era offers a sobering lesson in how both liberal theology and conservative evangelicalism, each in its own way, can contribute to the destruction of the Church.
The Trap of Liberal Theology: “Spiritual Euthanasia” through the Loss of Transcendence
Nineteenth-century German theologians such as Schleiermacher, Ritschl, and Harnack sought to make Christianity credible to intellectuals shaped by the Enlightenment. In doing so, they diminished or rejected elements such as biblical miracles, divine judgment, the virgin birth, and substitutionary atonement.
The Bible was increasingly reduced to a guidebook of noble human ethics and universal love.
The results of this experiment were deeply troubling.
Twentieth-century American theologian H. Richard Niebuhr famously mocked the emptiness of this form of liberal theology:
“A God without wrath brought men without sin into a kingdom without judgment through the ministrations of a Christ without a cross.”
If there is no hell, no sin, no resurrection, why sacrifice a Sunday morning’s sleep to sit in church?
Having lost spiritual tension and the wonder of transcendent salvation, many liberal Mainline churches of Europe and North America gradually began to resemble museums.
Liberal theology did not destroy the Church by setting it on fire. It placed the Church in warm water, allowing it slowly to fall asleep, until it underwent a kind of spiritual euthanasia.
The Evangelical Trap: “Moral Suicide” Committed in the Name of Orthodoxy
But did conservative evangelicalism, with its unwavering conviction that every word of Scripture is the infallible Word of God, save the Church?
Racism Hidden Behind Biblical Inerrancy in the American South
In the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, many conservative white churches in the American South proclaimed the absolute inerrancy of Scripture with extraordinary fervor.
Yet with those same mouths, some used the Bible to justify slavery, blessed white-supremacist organizations such as the Ku Klux Klan, and resisted Black Christians seeking equal participation in church life.
Their theology might have been thoroughly fundamentalist, but their lives could be profoundly anti-Christlike.
The Fall of Televangelists and the Bargain with Political Power
In the 1980s, celebrity evangelists such as Jim Bakker and Jimmy Swaggart gathered enormous contributions while loudly demanding that Christians “believe the Bible,” only to become engulfed in financial and sexual scandals.
In the twenty-first century, portions of white American evangelicalism developed increasingly close relationships with political forces promising to protect their religious influence, while White Christian Nationalism became a growing temptation.
The result has been a profound alienation of many younger Americans from institutional Christianity. Some have effectively concluded, “If this is the Jesus they represent, I would rather be an atheist,” contributing to the phenomenon often described as dechurching.
3. 140 Years of Korean Christianity: Miracle and Ruin in a Land Where Liberalism Never Dominated
The history of Korean Christianity provides one of the clearest and most painful case studies in this question.
The Korean Church has never experienced a period in which liberal theology completely dominated its religious landscape. Instead, Korea became one of the strongest bastions of conservative evangelical Christianity in the world.
The Tears of Pyongyang and the Humiliation of Shrine Worship
The driving force behind the Pyongyang Great Revival of 1907 was not sophisticated theological debate.
It was the public repentance of missionary Robert Hardie and the anguished confession of Elder Gil Seon-ju: “I took money that belonged to my deceased friend.”
When repentance was accompanied by ethical renewal, honesty, opposition to concubinage, temperance, and the breaking down of social barriers, the Gospel spread like wildfire.
Yet only thirty years later, in 1938, the 27th General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in Korea approved participation in Japanese Shinto shrine worship, arguing under colonial pressure that shrine worship was “not a religious act but a patriotic national ceremony.”
With the exception of a small number of resisters and martyrs such as Rev. Ju Gi-cheol, many leaders of denominations known for their highly conservative view of Scripture bowed before the shrines.
The denomination did not fall because it had been contaminated by liberal theology. It surrendered because of cowardice in the face of survival, coercion, and institutional self-interest.
The 1959 Division: “The WCC Is Communist” versus “Cry Out for Social Justice”
Following liberation and the Korean War, Korean Presbyterianism fragmented bitterly.
The Progressive/Liberal Camp: PROK and Minjung Theology
The Presbyterian Church in the Republic of Korea (PROK), associated with Rev. Kim Jae-jun and his rejection of strict biblical literalism, and the Minjung theologians of the 1970s and 1980s played significant roles in struggles for workers, the poor, democracy, and human rights under military dictatorship.
They often fulfilled an important social-prophetic role. Yet their intense focus on liberation and social engagement sometimes coincided with a weakening of congregational evangelistic passion and limited numerical church growth.
The Conservative/Evangelical Camp: Presbyterian Mainstream Denominations
In 1959, conflict concerning participation in the World Council of Churches (WCC) helped divide conservative Korean Presbyterianism. Opponents denounced the WCC as pro-Communist and religiously pluralistic, and the Presbyterian Church divided into major factions.
The conservative camp subsequently grew explosively through a combination of biblical inerrancy, anti-Communism, intense evangelism, and what critics describe as elements of prosperity theology.
The message that believing in Jesus would bring success in business and educational advancement for one’s children resonated with the social aspirations surrounding South Korea’s rapid economic development. Together with churches such as Yoido Full Gospel Church, Korea produced some of the world’s largest megachurches.
The Collapse of the Contemporary Korean Church: Liberalism or Mammon?
Since the 2000s, the Korean Church has faced a dramatic decline. Sunday schools have disappeared from many congregations, younger generations in their twenties and thirties are leaving churches, and public trust has deteriorated severely.
Conservative Christian leaders continue to argue that the Church is in crisis because of leftist ideology, anti-discrimination legislation, support for homosexuality, and liberal theology.
But the reasons ordinary citizens and younger generations have turned away from churches are not necessarily found in theology textbooks.
The Kingdom of Hereditary Succession
Some internationally prominent megachurches have altered or circumvented denominational rules in order to transfer enormous church institutions, properties, and congregational influence from senior pastors to their children.
Ethical Collapse among Pastors
Cases involving embezzlement, breach of fiduciary duty, sexual abuse and grooming, and academic plagiarism by prominent pastors have repeatedly appeared in Korean news media.
Gwanghwamun Politics and Fake News
The public has also become exhausted by images of extreme right-wing political pastors appearing to represent conservative Christianity, inflammatory rhetoric concerning God, and weekend demonstrations in which Korean and American flags are waved amid angry political denunciations.
What is sinking the Korean Church is not Bultmann’s demythologization or the methods of higher criticism. Most ordinary churchgoers do not even know who Bultmann was.
The deeper problem has been the hypocrisy of evangelicalism when those who passionately proclaim biblical inerrancy become corrupted by money and power.
Two Cliffs, and the Cross
History bears witness to two distinct roads by which the Church can destroy itself.
The Road of Intellectual Pride and Secularization: The Extreme of Liberalism
The Church loses its fear of the living God and its proclamation of a transcendent Gospel, reducing itself to little more than a humanitarian NGO and thereby eroding the reason for its own existence.
The Road of Spiritual Hypocrisy and Greed: The Extreme of Corrupted Evangelicalism
Its members cry out, “Scripture alone! Faith alone!” with passionate intensity, yet in practice become intoxicated with Mammon, money, privilege, and political power, sometimes behaving more shamefully than the secular world they condemn.
If liberal theology stopped the beating heart of the Gospel and allowed the Church to wither slowly, corrupted evangelicalism has sold the name of the Gospel for its own gain, turning the Church into an object of social disgust and effectively blowing it apart from within.
In the end, the lifeline of the Church has never depended simply on the theological labels “liberal” or “evangelical.”
Whether its theology is flexible or strict, the Church has found new life whenever it has repented of its own sins and practiced the self-giving love of the Cross.
And whenever it has raised the banner of orthodoxy while practicing greed, deception, and hypocrisy, it has inevitably collapsed before the judgment seat of history.
The old man leans on the frame of his bed the way a reed leans on the wind, and he rises one last time.
Luz comes back to him: a stone for a pillow, a ladder of fire, and a voice that said, “I will make you fruitful.” Through all his winters that promise kept burning in him like a coal.
Rachel comes back too, laid by the road to Ephrath. Sorrow and blessing have long shared one room in his heart.
His sight is dimming the way the stars fade before the sun. “Who are these?” Two boys born in Egypt are drawn into his arms.
“I never thought I’d see your face, and God has shown me your children.” Grace pours past the rim of what he had hoped.
Joseph arranges them by custom, the elder at the right. Then the old arms cross like branches over a single root.
“I know, my son. I know.” His eyes have gone dark, but his heart is lit by a light that doesn’t come from the sun.
And I ask myself: how often have I set my life in the order I thought was right, and called it wisdom? How often has Heaven crossed my plans and called it love?
He prays: “The God before whom my fathers walked, who has fed me all my days, the Angel who redeemed me from every evil— bless the boys.”
Bethel, Peniel, the limp, the long exile: his whole life is gathered into a single breath and given away.
“I am dying, but God will be with you.” The wick sinks low. The light moves on to other hands.
Hidden Redeemer, when I reach for the right hand, cross my hands gently. Teach me to bless the future You see and I cannot.
Five shepherds stood before the throne, dust of Canaan still in the folds of their robes. “Let your servants settle in Goshen.” And Pharaoh said, “The best of the land is yours.”
*
Then an old man was led in. “How many are your years?”
“One hundred thirty years of pilgrimage, few and hard.”
And the stranger lifted his hands and blessed the king.
The one with nothing to prove gave blessing to the one with everything.
*
Outside, the famine deepened. Silver ran out. Then horses, sheep, and donkeys. Then fields. Then the people themselves.
“Give us seed, that we may live and not die.”
Joseph gave them seed: one fifth for Pharaoh, four fifths for their children. “You have saved our lives.”
*
In Goshen Israel grew fruitful and multiplied.
Seventeen more years. One hundred forty-seven in all.
Then Jacob called his son. “Put your hand under my thigh. Do not bury me in Egypt. Carry me to my fathers.”
“I will.” “Swear it.” And Joseph swore.
*
Fed by Egypt, welcomed by Egypt, Jacob still did not belong to Egypt.
Take today’s bread with gratitude and keep your eyes on the promise.
At the head of his bed the old pilgrim bowed, not in defeat but in trust, already turned toward home.
I could not stand among the white stones at Arlington when they laid you down. But I had the years, and the years were enough.
*
I first came to you as a chaplain, to a room at the care center in Mountain Home, after your third stroke. You rose from that bed better than anyone expected.
Then, before the house next door was even on the market, you told me about it. Within a few months we were neighbors.
*
The backyard became our chapel. Hour after hour you told me your story: twice a prisoner of war in North Korea, then a long life in uniform.
When your wife was taken in a traffic accident, the stories kept going, quieter now, and heavier.
In the end you packed up and moved to Morehead City to live beside your daughter.
*
I made one last trip. We sat on the beach and watched the Atlantic for an hour, saying very little.
It was enough.
We said goodbye without words, because our hearts already knew.
*
Bob, soldier, prisoner, survivor, neighbor, friend, thank you for your service, and for your friendship.
One day we will embrace again across a grateful, gracious ocean.
You must be logged in to post a comment.